Follow us

    • Home
    • Politics
    • Science
    • News
    • World
    • Business
    • National
    • Sports
    • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Opinion
    • Tech
    Thursday, June 1, 2023
    27 °c
    Labadi
    28 ° Mon
    28 ° Tue
    28 ° Wed
    28 ° Thu
    • Login
    • Register
    The New Crusading Guide Online
    • Home
    • Politics
    • News
    • Africa
    • World
    • Business
    • Lifestyle
    • Tech
    • Entertainment
    • Your News
    • More News
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • Politics
    • News
    • Africa
    • World
    • Business
    • Lifestyle
    • Tech
    • Entertainment
    • Your News
    • More News
    No Result
    View All Result
    The New Crusading Guide Online
    No Result
    View All Result
    Home National

    The $6 Million Appiatse Disaster Fine Imposed on MAXAM Explosives Company is Insignificant – Dr. Solomon Owusu

    February 12, 2022
    in National, News, Politics, Social Media, Your News
    Reading Time: 7 mins read
    A A
    0
    The $6 Million Appiatse Disaster Fine Imposed on MAXAM Explosives Company is Insignificant – Dr. Solomon Owusu
    6.6k
    SHARES
    7.6k
    VIEWS
    Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

     

    The press release on the Appiatse incident report dated on February 7, 2022 should not be accepted by Ghanaians, especially the good people of Appiatse, because of its shameful, heartless and disappointing nature. Technically, the whole 6-paged release looks incomplete, amateurish, shocking and indicates a display of a cover-up to prevent certain perpetrators from receiving consequences resulting from their negligence and non-compliance. In my humble opinion, all the affected people of the Appiatse incident should be properly indemnified physically, emotionally psychologically and financially with adequate resource mobilization.

     

    The Minister’s US$6.0 million fine imposed on MAXAM company for breaching the explosives regulations is a pittance and I therefore write to admonish all Ghanaians, whether home or abroad to reject the half-baked press release, which has the potentials to worsen the woes of the public in terms of setting a bad precedent for the future. Comparing with compensations awarded to communities that experienced similar disaster in other countries, the Appiatse people deserve a minimum of US$350 million.  It must be noted that, previous breaches by MAXAM in 2017 means under international human rights law, that the government’s failure to act to prevent these foreseeable risks to life is a violation of the rights to life.

    Related posts

    Shocking Apiatse Report- Dr. Solomon Owusu

    Shocking Apiatse Report- Dr. Solomon Owusu

    February 8, 2022
    7.7k
    Minister Receives Report Of Appiatse Investigative Committee

    Minister Receives Report Of Appiatse Investigative Committee

    February 2, 2022
    7.5k
    Processes To Rebuild Community Commences

    Processes To Rebuild Community Commences

    January 28, 2022
    7.5k
    The Appiate Explosion:  Prez Akufo-Addo Donates GH¢100,000 Support Fund

    The Appiate Explosion: Prez Akufo-Addo Donates GH¢100,000 Support Fund

    January 28, 2022
    7.6k

     

    From a professional stance, this horrific explosion could have been prevented if the international standard processes and procedures for transporting explosives were stringently followed. As I stated in my preliminary opinion on the unfortunate explosion, the tragic incident that happened was due to negligence, regulatory lapses and institutional failures. Considering the entirety of the press release, it is clear that the causes of the catastrophic incident were as a result of these three factors. The disaster took away thirteen (13) lives, caused various degrees of injuries of over hundreds of people, rendered lots of residents homeless, destroyed uncountable properties and collapsed the whole Appiatse Community. It is similar to past incidents in other countries, where the responsible mining companies were ordered to pay billions of United States dollars.

     

    As a follow up to the incident which happened on January 20, 2022, the Sector Minister in Charge of Mining in Ghana instructed the Minerals Commission, which is the regulator of the mining industry to conduct investigations. Also, the Minister constituted a three-member committee to carry out independent investigations into the matter to confirm the Minerals Commission’s findings. The two separate reports were submitted to the Minister in less than two weeks after the incident. Strangely, the two reports from which the press release was excerpted, have not yet been disclosed to the public for unknown reasons. Upon reviewing the reports, the Ministry of Lands and Natural Resources established that MAXAM Ghana Limited committed regulatory breaches that led to the tragic incident, with respect to the manufacture, storage and transportation of the explosives.

     

    Per the Legislative Instrument (LI 2177) which is the law governing all explosive activities in Ghana, MAXAM’s breaches should have attracted fines up to US$10,000. Considering the nature and the totality of the incident, the Minister in his wisdom imposed a total administrative fine of US$6.0 million on MAXAM. He needs to be commended for this swift action. The company is expected to pay an initial US$1.0 million before the restoration of its operating permit and then settle the remaining within 18 months, ending on August 1, 2023. However, I think the installment payment should be scrapped since the fine should not only be based on financial capacity of the MAXAM in Ghana but the company’s group which is well resourced to pay the peanuts imposed on them.

     

    From the press release, the fine to be paid is without prejudice to any criminal or civil liability that MAXAM may be subject to. This means, any individual or group of people from the accident area can initiate a lawsuit against MAXAM and the other two companies whose truck caused the disaster. Again, in order for the company to operate in safe manner, compliance measures were set by the Minister as guidelines for MAXAM to strictly follow. Surprisingly, the Minister’s press release was silent on the regulatory breaches and possible sanctions against the local explosives transporting contractors, Jocyderk Logistics Limited and Arthanns Enterprise Transport Services, whose truck was directly involved in the incident.

     

    It is on record that MAXAM company contracted these local entities to transport their explosives on the highway from Tarkwa to Chirano Mine, considering the 30% local content policy. Although, MAXAM sublet its transportation duty to these local companies, it had the oversight responsibility to ensure that they adhered to strict health, safety and environment standards to protect lives and properties. Analyzing the press release critically, it can be deduced that the two committees’ work in less than two weeks are questionable in terms of:

    1. The quantification of loss of lives and injuries associated with the tragic incident.
    2. The evaluation of social and cultural losses of the Appiatse community.
    3. Failure to recognize that the cost of the environmental degradation from the explosion alone will be over hundreds of millions of dollars.
    4. The factors that the Minister considered in the reports to justify the US$ 6 million fine.
    5. The credibility of the report from the Minerals Commission, which is itself implicated in the disaster, because of the suspected neglect of duty from their part as well.
    6. The public’s trust in the chairman of independent committee, whose tenure as the CEO of Minerals Commission in 2012, approved the LI 2012 with various regulatory lapses.
    7. Details in the two reports to justify the imposition of sanctions and possible prosecutions of the explosives transport contractors and some officials from the Minerals Commission.
    8. Failure to explain the incomplete investigations with findings on the part of Arthanns Transport Company and appropriate sanctions announced? How long does the public have to wait for this?
    9. Failure by the Minister to cite the exact breaches of regulations on the part of MAXAM Company to justify the fine and determine subsequent prosecution.
    10. Reluctance by the Ministry to disclose the two committees’ reports to the public.

     

    Although the Minister should be commended for applying his veto powers to determine the administrative fine, which is far more than the stipulated amounts in the laws, the criteria for the fine should have been backed by current assessment of damages. Again, details of the professional assessment of the losses should have been detailed in the press release to convince the public. Seriously, the fine must reflect international standards, based on past experiences in other countries that led to fines worth billions of US dollars. Failure to drastically penalize the perpetrators will set a bad precedent for any unforeseen future occurrence.

     

    In my view, reparation and damage clean up impositions on some mining companies for causing similar disasters in other countries, should have been studied and analyzed to serve as guidelines to ensure that informed and acceptable decisions were taken before defining any sanction in connection with the catastrophic disaster. The fine stated in the press release was far below standards and had conflicting reflection on the quantum of the calamitous disaster. The current Ghana government will render serious disservice to the people of Appiatse, if it fails to ensure that the right compensations are rewarded to the people.

     

    Concerning the fine, Vale Iron Ore Mine disaster in Brazil that happened on January 25, 2019  (https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/judge-orders-vale-pay-victims-families-2019-mining-disaster-2021-06-10/) and (https://www.bbc.com/news/business-55924743), involving tailings dam collapse that led to two hundred and seventy (270) loss of lives could be used as an example. In addition, Samarco Iron Ore Mine tailings dam collapse which occurred in Brazil on November 5, 2015 that killed nineteen (19) people could be used as a benchmark to determine the fines for MAXAM’s negligence (https://mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSKCN0W42WP).

     

    Moreover, the punishments meted out to perpetrators of a deadly methane blast in a coal mining company in Russia on November 27, 2021 (https://www.rferl.org/amp/russia-kemerovo-mining-disaster-investigation/31582405.html), could be used as a reference to initiate prosecution processes for those whose neglect of duty caused the disaster. All in all, the Brazilian and Russian governments ensured that charges and fines were imposed on the responsible companies and the people connected to the three disasters, in order to calm down public emotions and helped in building new lives on the rubbles of unprecedented tragedies.

     

    On February 4, 2021, the Brazilian government went into agreement with Vale Mining Company to pay US$ 7 billion to the community hit by the disaster, where about two hundred and seventy (270) people were killed. Also, the family of each deceased employee was compensated with US$197,240. The responsible senior staff of the company whose carelessness caused the disaster faced murder charges. Again, Vale was instructed to fully repair all environmental damages, including clean-up of the Paraopeba river, sewage treatment, landfill, reforestation, among others.

     

    On March 2, 2016, the Brazilian government estimated US$ 5.1 billion in damages to be paid by the Samarco Mining Company for the deadly tailings dam spill that took away 19 lives, destroyed about 200 homes, rendered hundreds of people homeless and polluted the major river in the area. Also, charges of manslaughter and environmental damages were filed against twenty-one (21) executives of the company. Besides, the fine did not cover private civil lawsuits and other criminal investigations.

     

    A court in the city of Kemerovo in Russia on November 27, 2021, ruled to jail three officials of Listvyazhnaya Coal Mining Company to face a maximum of seven (7) years in prison for violating industrial safety requirements for hazards production facilities that resulted in multiple deaths. These are the company’s director, Sergei Makhrakov, his deputy, Andrei Molostvov and the section supervisor, Sergei Gerasimyonok. Additionally, two other people, Sergei Vinokurov and Vyacheslav Semykin, who were officials of the local branch of Russia’s state technology and ecology watchdog, were jailed to face up to seven (7) years in prison for their negligence that led to the disaster. These two officials issued a certificate for the mine’s operation within the month that the incident occurred, without actually checking the facility. The methane explosion killed forty-six (46) miners and five (5) rescuers.

     

    Considering these previous similar tragic incidents and their corresponding compensations, prosecutions and environmental liabilities imposed on the parties involved, it is hopeful that the Ghana government will ensure that better decisions are taken to enable the people of Appiatse to deserve better. Furthermore, all persons whose negligence caused the catastrophic disaster should face the full strictness of the law to serve as deterrent to others, thereby preventing possible future recurrence. Due to the public doubts in the current investigative reports, a trustworthy independent investigation team should be immediately constituted to conduct thorough inquiry into the explosion and provide acceptable recommendations for implementation.

     

    In my opinion, the public will wholeheartedly welcome such a credible report from the trusted independent committee. Proper sanctions and fines should be slapped on the companies and institution(s) involved, as well as legitimate punishments meted out to individuals whose neglect of duty led to the disaster. With these, the psychological trauma of the Appiatse people will be minimized and help in building new lives on the rubbles of the unprecedented tragedy that visited them. More importantly, stern punishments will serve as wake-up call to all public and private sector workers in Ghana, who neglect their duties to cause avoidable accidents.

     

    Solomon Owusu, PhD.

    (Mining Engineering & Mineral Economics Consultant)

    Colorado, USA.

     

    Related

    Tags: apiateapiatseappiate
    Share2625Tweet1641SendShare

    Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

    Unsubscribe
    Previous Post

    Okyenhene Petitioned Over Fake Signature

    Next Post

    NLA Strikes! …Arrests 7 Illegal Lotto Kingpins In Kumasi

    News Desk

    News Desk

    Related Posts

    Businessman Clarifies ISD Land Tussle  
    More News

    Businessman Clarifies ISD Land Tussle  

    June 1, 2023
    7.5k
    MARKET QUEENS PICK FOR ALAN  …Believe He Is Capable Of ‘Breaking the 8’ for NPP
    Ghana

    MARKET QUEENS PICK FOR ALAN …Believe He Is Capable Of ‘Breaking the 8’ for NPP

    June 1, 2023
    7.5k
    Illegal Lotto Operator Dribbles Draw Winners  …Over 1 Million Cedis Win, NLA to apply Sanctions
    Social Media

    Porsche Lotteries Denies Dribbling Draw Winners …Over 1 Million Cedis Win, States Its Case

    May 31, 2023
    7.5k
    48 Illegal Miners Trapped In AngloGold Mine Shaft Arrested
    Ghana

    48 Illegal Miners Trapped In AngloGold Mine Shaft Arrested

    May 31, 2023
    7.5k
    Dr. Kokofu Grabs Top Award At Ghana CEO Summit
    More News

    Dr. Kokofu Grabs Top Award At Ghana CEO Summit

    May 31, 2023
    7.5k
    Ghanaian Real Estate Developers Set To Showcase Properties In Toronto Canada
    Africa

    Ghanaian Real Estate Developers Set To Showcase Properties In Toronto Canada

    May 31, 2023
    7.5k
    Next Post
    NLA Strikes!  …Arrests 7 Illegal Lotto Kingpins In Kumasi

    NLA Strikes! ...Arrests 7 Illegal Lotto Kingpins In Kumasi

    NPA Reviewing Act To Meet International Standards

    NPA Reviewing Act To Meet International Standards

    Osu Installs New Mantse

    Osu Installs New Mantse

    DCE’s ‘Machomen’ Attack School Feeding Caterers In Amansie Central  …Pour & Damage Meals For School Children

    DCE’s ‘Machomen’ Attack School Feeding Caterers In Amansie Central …Pour & Damage Meals For School Children

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Facebook Twitter
    • Dr. Stephen Amoah Discovers Formula To Raise Ghana From Economic Doldrums

      Dr. Stephen Amoah Discovers Formula To Raise Ghana From Economic Doldrums

      10907 shares
      Share 4363 Tweet 2727
    • Okyenhene Warns KOANS …To Stay Away From Akyem Lands 

      10381 shares
      Share 4152 Tweet 2595
    • Supreme Court Exposes Estate Developer …Over Fraudulent Judgement Against Jeleel 

      7974 shares
      Share 3190 Tweet 1994
    • Muntaka, Bailiff Showdown @East Lagon Police Station

      7854 shares
      Share 3142 Tweet 1964
    • Twumasiwaa Hospital Killer Grabbed …Detailed Accounts Of How NIB Nabbed Main Suspect Within 48Hrs

      7824 shares
      Share 3130 Tweet 1956
    • Trending
    • Comments
    • Latest
    Dr. Stephen Amoah Discovers Formula To Raise Ghana From Economic Doldrums

    Dr. Stephen Amoah Discovers Formula To Raise Ghana From Economic Doldrums

    June 15, 2022 - Updated on March 20, 2023
    Okyenhene Angry At Forest Invaders

    Okyenhene Warns KOANS …To Stay Away From Akyem Lands 

    July 18, 2022 - Updated on August 23, 2022
    Ecobank Shows Gross Disrespect To Supreme Court

    Supreme Court Exposes Estate Developer …Over Fraudulent Judgement Against Jeleel 

    March 11, 2022
    2018 budget GOV’T TOUTS ECONOMIC GROWTH …But Minority Ridicules Strides

    Muntaka, Bailiff Showdown @East Lagon Police Station

    August 15, 2021
    Alarm Blows!! Over 1,200 Companies Caught Evading Tax, Money Laundering

    Alarm Blows!! Over 1,200 Companies Caught Evading Tax, Money Laundering

    2
    Furious Winds Blow Over NTHC …Customers Up-In-Arms Over Dividends, Investment As Company Limps

    Furious Winds Blow Over NTHC …Customers Up-In-Arms Over Dividends, Investment As Company Limps

    2

    Why Asantehene is a King – A rejoinder

    1
    Ga East MCE Hot  …For Demolishing Properties Belonging to Kwabenya Queenmother

    Queen Mother Floors Ga East MCE In Court …Over Kwabenya Market Lands

    1
    Businessman Clarifies ISD Land Tussle  

    Businessman Clarifies ISD Land Tussle  

    June 1, 2023
    MARKET QUEENS PICK FOR ALAN  …Believe He Is Capable Of ‘Breaking the 8’ for NPP

    MARKET QUEENS PICK FOR ALAN …Believe He Is Capable Of ‘Breaking the 8’ for NPP

    June 1, 2023
    Illegal Lotto Operator Dribbles Draw Winners  …Over 1 Million Cedis Win, NLA to apply Sanctions

    Porsche Lotteries Denies Dribbling Draw Winners …Over 1 Million Cedis Win, States Its Case

    May 31, 2023
    48 Illegal Miners Trapped In AngloGold Mine Shaft Arrested

    48 Illegal Miners Trapped In AngloGold Mine Shaft Arrested

    May 31, 2023
    Gettsorted Freelance platform
    ADVERTISEMENT

    Follow us on Instagram

    Follow us on Instagram

      Tweets

      Businessman Clarifies ISD Land Tussle  

      Businessman Clarifies ISD Land Tussle  

      June 1, 2023
      MARKET QUEENS PICK FOR ALAN  …Believe He Is Capable Of ‘Breaking the 8’ for NPP

      MARKET QUEENS PICK FOR ALAN …Believe He Is Capable Of ‘Breaking the 8’ for NPP

      June 1, 2023
      Illegal Lotto Operator Dribbles Draw Winners  …Over 1 Million Cedis Win, NLA to apply Sanctions

      Porsche Lotteries Denies Dribbling Draw Winners …Over 1 Million Cedis Win, States Its Case

      May 31, 2023
      ADVERTISEMENT
      The New Crusading GUIDE is a privately own newspaper in Ghana with Mr Abdul Malik Kweku Baako as its Editor-In-Chief. The Deputy Editor-In-Chief is Anas Aremeyaw Anas, the International undercover investigative journalist. We give you the latest news

      Follow us on Instagram

        Tags

        2018 League Africa airbus Anas apiate apiatse appiate Australia Balinese Culture Bali United bogoso Budget Travel Champions League China Chopper Bike coronavirus corruption Côte d’Ivoire Ebony EC Election Results entertainment Europe France Gaza Germany Ghana Israel NDC News Nigeria North Korea NPP Reviews Russia South Africa South Korea Spain Tech Tunisia UK Ukraine US world Zimbabwe
        • About
        • Advertise
        • Careers
        • Privacy & Policy
        • Contact
        • About

        © 2022 The New Crusading Online - All rights Reserved. Powered by Uthink.

        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • Politics
        • Science
        • News
        • World
        • Business
        • National
        • Sports
        • Entertainment
        • Lifestyle
        • Travel
        • Opinion
        • Tech

        © 2022 The New Crusading Online - All rights Reserved. Powered by Uthink.

        Welcome Back!

        Login to your account below

        Forgotten Password? Sign Up

        Create New Account!

        Fill the forms below to register

        All fields are required. Log In

        Retrieve your password

        Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

        Log In
        Manage Cookie Consent
        To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
        Functional Always active
        The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
        Preferences
        The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
        Statistics
        The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
        Marketing
        The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
        Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
        View preferences
        {title} {title} {title}
        This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
        x Logo: Shield Security
        This Site Is Protected By
        Shield Security →